Showing posts with label ESL. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ESL. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Updating and Adding to Your Portfolio Assessment

In the past, I've discussed the rationale for portfolio assessment and how to start your own portfolio assessment system for your ESOL students. Hopefully by now, you've already begun your portfolios and included basic information, as well as some baseline assessments in reading, writing, speaking, and listening. So....now what?

What sorts of things should you be putting into your portfolios? Remember that you are including work from all four modalities, reading, writing, speaking and listening. Using work from all subject areas that you study (math, science, social studies, etc), as long as it includes language is fine.
  • Anecdotal notes- Make notes daily (and date them) about the things the student is struggling with, as well as what he or she is doing well. Also include other information that may be relevant, such as if the student appears tired or hungry. Make notes of behavior issues also. All of these things contribute to the student's ability to do well in school.
  • Classroom activities- The items that you include should be authentic. Don't have designated "portfolio activities", but rather choose items to go in the portfolio from authentic work that your students have completed in class. One of the ways that portfolio assessment differs from other formal assessments (tests) is that students are not aware of what will go in their portfolios when they are working on it and don't feel like they are being "tested". 
  • Testing Accommodations- Keep a copy of the student's testing accommodations form in the portfolio with the other biographical information. Also, use this FREE Testing Accommodations Record form to record the testing accommodations you provide for classroom tests and keep a copy in the portfolio. Remember, you are required to provide testing accommodations on ALL classroom tests, not just district and state tests!
  • Work that your student has struggled with or done poorly on- The tendency with a portfolio is to think that you should only put the student's BEST work in. However, this is not the case withan assessment portfolio. While you do want to include some of the student's best work to show how well he or she is doing, the idea of a portfolio is to demonstrate all aspects of the student's learning, not just where he or she excels. When you put in work or skills that the student has struggled with, then you can target those skills, and your portfolio will have room to show growth as well. 
  • Rubrics- You should include a rubric assessing each activity according to your state or districts English Language development standards.If your state or district does not have their own, I recommend using these Speaking and Writing Rubrics from WIDA, or you can purchase the Reading Comprehension Rubric or the Baseline Writing Rubric that are available in my TpT store.
One thing that many teachers struggle with is how to assess student speaking or listening informally. One way to do this is during pair-share time. Students should spend at least a little time each day explaining a new concept or idea to a classmate. Circulate and listen as students chat. Use the WiDA speaking rubric linked above to assess what students say to one another. You can create another rubric to measure listening. Then ask the student to retell what their classmate said, and use the rubric to assess his or her listening skills. Group presentations are another time when you can assess a student's listening or speaking abilities. However, please remember when assessing speaking that accent is not important, as long as it does not impede understanding.

Please let me know how your portfolio assessment is going!

Monday, September 19, 2011

Strategy of the Week

STRATEGY-
Clock Buddies
This strategy is more of a grouping strategy to ensure that your students get lots of interaction with lots of different students in the class. We all know that students tend to group with the same partner during pair-share or pair-work time. When they interact with the same student all the time, their input opportunities are limited.
When we vary the partners that our students have, we vary their exposure to different backgrounds and points of view as well. Using the “clock buddies” strategy helps to mix up the partners that each student gets.

Here’s how it works:
1.     At the beginning of the day (or the week), give each student a “clock buddies” worksheet.
2.     Have the students mix and mingle to make “appointments” with one another. They can make appointments by writing a different classmate’s name on each of their clock slots. The student whose name they wrote at 9 am (for example) should have their name in the same time slot.
3.     When you need to pair students up, you can ask them to look at their clock worksheets and meet up with their “3 o’clock buddy” (for example). 

Click the picture below to download the Clock Buddies Appointment Sheet (free!)
 



Sunday, September 11, 2011

Strategy of the Week (and a freebie!)

STRATEGY-
Zip Around
This activity provides students with a chance to apply content knowledge and practice content vocabulary while developing their listening and speaking skills.
Identify the important vocabulary and facts for practice or review. Create the pattern you will use on a piece of notebook paper to ensure that you will have answers for each question and that your cards will enable you to return to the starting question. Remember that the answer should not match the question on the same card, but rather will answer the question from the card preceding it. Make sure that there is only one answer for each question included. Write the questions into the template or onto index cards.

For example one card might say: “I have soil. Who has what plants need to make their own food?” The card that follows that would read “I have sunlight. Who has the part that plants use to take water from the soil?” The third card would then read,  "I have roots. Who has the part of the plant containing the reproductive organs?"   Clearly, this strategy can be adapted for many different content areas and topics.

Print these cards out on cardstock and laminate before playing to make them last longer.
  1. Mix up the cards, and then pass one out to each student.
  2. The first student to go should not read his or her “I have”, but instead begin with “Who has….?”
  3. The student who has the answer responds with “I have….”. “Who has…?”
  4. This pattern continues until each student has read his/her answer and question and you end with the student who began.
For the FREE TEMPLATE I created, click the picture below. You can also find a ready-to-go Solar System Zip-Around in my TpT store

ENJOY!!!




Thursday, September 8, 2011

A freebie!

This year I am working with fourth graders at my school, and one homeroom class has several newcomer students who don't know their numbers in English yet. To help them as they're learning, I created these Spanish-English number charts. I plan to print them back-to-back, laminate them, and then punch them with a three-hole punch so that the students can put them in their notebooks and always have them to refer back to. So, I'm offering this as a freebie for you too! It can also be useful to Spanish teachers who are teaching the numbers.

CLICK THE PICTURE TO DOWNLOAD THIS FREEBIE!!

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

What should I know about my ESOL students?

As we return to school each year, we face the daunting task of getting to know our students. Teachers can have anywhere from 20 to 120 students to get to know each year- the task can be fun, but that's a lot of kids to learn about!

Knowing specific information about your ESL students in particular can help you to better serve them. Here are some things that you might want to find out about your ESL students:
  • Home language- Knowing a student's home language can help you when communicating with family, but it can also help you instructionally, especially when the student is literate in his or her native language. For example, Spanish speaking students can benefit from knowledge of cognates. Knowing a student's home language can also better help you understand some of the student's language difficulties as well. For example, many Asian languages do not use articles, so many Asian ELLs have difficulty using articles in English. 
  • English speakers in the home- Knowing whether or not a parent or someone else at home speaks English not only facilitates communication with parents and guardians, but it also can give you an insight into how much academic help is available to the student at home.
  • Student's country of birth and family country of origin- Did you know that many students who receive ESL services and who speak another language in the home are born in the United States? That is not to say there are plenty born in other countries, but a good portion of the ESL population is American-born. However, their parents usually came here from another country and it is important to know which country, so that you can better understand the family culture. For students who did come here from another country, understanding the student's culture can help you to build a stronger relationship with the student.
  • Student's entry date into US Schools- In most cases, this is a good indicator of how long the student has been in US schools. The rare exception is the student who was in US schools for a year and then perhaps returned to the home country for another year or more. Knowing how much schooling a student has had in the US can be a good indicator of whether or not the student is progressing steadily in his or her English language development.
  • Who the student lives with- Understanding the family dynamics can better help you to understand any problems the student may have and can better help you understand whether the student is struggling because of language, or because maybe something else is going on in the home. Many ESL students may have left parents or siblings behind in another country, and may be living with aunts or uncles. Some students may live with extended family. Some students may have many younger siblings and be expected to help with their care. Knowing these things about your student may help you to understand why homework is not completed or why a child falls asleep in class.
The more we know about our students, the better we can understand them. When we understand where our students are coming from, we can provide the best instruction and support possible.

Monday, August 22, 2011

ESOL Mythbusters

It is time to go back to school, and that means that many teachers are meeting their students for the first time. Some teachers may be surprised to learn that they have more students in their class who speak a second language in the home than they expected.

According to the National Council for Teachers of English, English Language Learners (ELLs) now comprise 10.5% of the K-12 student population. Furthermore, in grades 7-12, the number of ELLs increased 70% between 1992 and 2002. So, it makes sense to take a closer look at some of those myths about ELLs and BUST them!

Myth: A student has acquired a second language once he or she can speak it.
As I discussed in this article, there are two types of language that we acquire when learning a second language. The first is Basic Interpersonal Communication Skills (BICS), which allow us to complete everyday tasks like following directions, making small talk, and asking and answering questions. The other type of language we acquire is called Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (CALPs). This is the type of language that allows us to be successful in a school environment- academic vocabulary and structure. Research shows that it takes approximately 1-2 years to master BICS, and 5-7 years (or more) to master CALPs. Educators must be aware of and make the distinction between the two types of language in order to properly assess their student's level of language proficiency. A good example for most teachers is to think back to your own foreign-language learning in high school or college. Unless you majored in foreign language, you likely acquired only enough of that language to be a successful tourist or at most, a conversationalist. If you were placed in an academic environment with that level of language, you would have a very difficult time, despite the fact that you "speak" the language!

Myth: Second language learning processes are the same for all students.
As teachers, we know that no two students are the same, and this goes for ELLs as well. Just because they have a common problem (a lack of English proficiency) does not mean that they all need the same materials and methods. Just as we are expected to differentiate for other students at different levels, we must also differentiate among our ELLs. Many teachers make the mistake of giving the same modified work to all ELLs in the class, regardless of their level of proficiency. This means that all of the ELLs are not having their needs met. A classroom teacher should consult with the ESOL teacher at his or her school to get copies of the results of the yearly English Language Proficiency test for each ELL in their class. If necessary, the teacher should ask the ESOL teacher to explain what the different levels of proficiency mean. Once the classroom teacher better understands the different levels of proficiency represented by the ELLs in his or her class, then he or she is better able to make appropriate differentiations to meet the needs of all ELLs in the class.

Myth: Teaching English Language Learners means focusing primarily on vocabulary.
While explicit vocabulary instruction is important and vital for English language learners, the teacher must remember that the vocabulary means nothing if the students are not able to understand it and use it in context. This means that they must also acquire the content of the subject area, and not just the vocabulary. Word walls are a great tool for newcomer ELLs, but I like to recommend sentence walls for older ELLs, especially in content area classes. Sentence walls can help ELLs put the vocabulary that they've used into the correct context and sentence structure for the content area.
  
Myth: Using strategies to help ELLs in my class will only benefit the ELLs.
The truth is that English language learners aren't the only ones struggling with reading, writing and understanding academic language- many of the native English speaking students in our schools are deficient in academic language. Using strategies and activities that help to teach and reinforce academic vocabulary and language structures will help ALL students who are behind in understanding and using academic language. 

Myth: Making modifications to lessons and classwork takes too much time.
I won't tell you that making modifications doesn't take time, because it does. However, many teachers often teach the same grades and/or classes for years at a time, and once you've modified some material- you have that modified material to make use of year after year. Some teachers become frustrated when talking about modifications because they picture themselves spending hours and hours creating special assignments for their ELL students and falling behind in creating assignments for other students. As with most things, there is a learning curve. I will say that the more you modify assignments and the better you know your students' abilities, the easier it will become to make appropriate modifications. I've written several articles about how to make simple modifications that you can read back on, but I'll quickly remind you that there are three specific ways you can modify an assignment:
  • Change the language process needed to complete the task- for example, instead of having students write a sentence to go with a picture, you might have an ELL match a picture to an already written sentence
  • Change the grouping strategy- for example, instead of having a student work independently, have ELLs work in pairs or triads, either with one another or with a native language buddy
  • Change the content delivery- for example, instead of the grade level text the rest of the class is using, ELLs might benefit from a lower-level text covering the same material, or you can change the text by simplifying or expounding the text
As always, I hope that this article helps you to better understand and serve your ELLs. If you have any questions, feel free to ask!

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Guidelines for grading ESL Students



One thing that many teachers struggle with is how to assign grades to the work that their ESL and LEP (Limited English Proficient) students do. They feel that because the student is completing modified work or working under testing accommodations, that it is unfair to give these students the same high grades that other students receive.

This is not the case. At the start, the playing field is not level for all students; as educators, we are aware of this. The modifications and accommodations are designed to level the playing field so that all students can be equally successful. If your student does stellar work on modified assignments, this means he or she should earn an A. Just because a student is getting A's on modified assignments, doesn't mean he or she doesn't need the modifications anymore.

Here are some guidelines, based on the federal laws, for grading your ESL and LEP students:

  • Students should not receive grades of “D” or “F” based on lack of English proficiency.  LEP students should not receive grades of D or F unless their lack of performance on modified instruction warrants such grades, for example…not completing modified assignments/homework, not turning in modified assignments/homework, not making satisfactory progress on modified work.
  •  LEP students will receive report card grades based on their work, modified as necessary in the regular classroom. 
  •  Classroom teachers should modify instruction, assignments, and tests based on students’ English language proficiencies. The use of instructional accommodations and modifications does not indicate that a student cannot receive the highest grade in the content area.
  • Testing accommodations should be given to all LEP students for every classroom test given. For a list of testing accommodations, see the ESL teachers or the LEP committee at your school.
  •  LEP students may receive language accommodations in the classroom while being instructed with the Standard Course of Study (state standards) on grade level.  These students have the ability to receive the highest grade attainable in the content area with use of language accommodations based on the student’s proficiency level.
  • Classroom teachers are required to maintain open communication with ESL teachers regarding appropriate expectations and assessment of ESL students.



Lau vs Nichols:
Equity of Educational Opportunity is not achieved by merely providing all students with “the same facilities, textbooks, teachers and curriculum; (because) students who do not understand English are effectively foreclosed from any meaningful education”.  All English Language Learners (ELLs) are entitled to equal access to the core curriculum and the curriculum must be made comprehensible to ELLs.


1983 Office of Civil Rights
“It is our policy to find a violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 if Limited English Proficient (LEP) students are retained in grade for failure to demonstrate basic skills in English.”

Monday, July 18, 2011

A day in the zapatos of an ELL


            What is it like to go to a new school in a new country where the language of instruction is not your first language? One of the fastest growing segments of the American student population is English language learners. Although schools are required to offer programs and services for English language learners, most of these students still spend the majority of their time in mainstream content classrooms. Sadly, most mainstream teachers have little or no training in how to meet the academic needs of someone who does not speak English as his or her first language.
            As a result, many English language learners never realize their full academic potential. Content teachers are asking themselves “what can I do?” when they find that English language learners are performing poorly in their content-area classes. There are some important steps that all teachers can take to help ensure the success of English language learners in their classrooms.
1.    Communicate with the ESL teacher at your school
The ESL teacher works closely with these students and will be familiar with each student's abilities and level of proficiency. The ESL teacher can also help identify each student's strengths and weaknesses, and offer advice on how to properly modify assignments and  readings. Furthermore, when the ESL instructor is aware of what the student is doing in content classes, he or she will be able to offer valuable instruction and guidance in an ESL setting that will assist the student in acquiring important vocabulary and language skills that he or she will need in the content classroom.
2.    Offer Modified Assignments for ESL students
Although it may take a few extra moments when preparing lesson plans, it is very important to
modify assignments and readings so that they contain language that is comprehensible to the student. If new or special vocabulary is required for understanding, then a special effort should be made to ensure that students acquire and use the new vocabulary properly before proceeding- sentence and word walls placed in visible areas around the classroom can be especially effective. Comprehensible does not mean easy- the work should still be challenging and require the use of higher cognitive skills. If you are particularly short on time, keep in mind that many topics can be found in simpler language by simply looking in the textbook of a lower grade level. If you have a large number of students, the extra time may seem like a burden, but it will be worth it when the English language learners in your classroom begin to understand the concepts that the rest of their classmates are learning.
3.    Be sure that assignments are meaningful
As with any student, be sure that assignments are meaningful and not just intended to keep the student busy. If assignments are not meaningful, then students will quickly become bored and will not learn as much. Meaningful assignments should be relevant to the material covered in class, comprehensible, and allow the student to make important connections between his world and what he is learning in the classroom.
4.    Place English language learners close to the front of the class
When English language learners are having difficulty, any distraction can be an excuse to tune out. Placing them near the front will help minimize distractions. Be sure that students understand that they are not being placed in the front because they are behaving or performing poorly, but that you want to do all that you can to help ensure their academic success.
5.    Hold English language learners responsible
When giving out quizzes or assignments, never tell an English language learner to “just write something down” or to “do what you can.” English language learners need specific instructions to follow and should be required to follow them. If everyone else in the class is doing an assignment or working on a project, then the English language learners should also be doing a meaningful activity that will help them acquire the required knowledge (this is where those modified assignments come in!). If an English language learner is not held responsible for classwork and homework related to the content, he or she cannot be expected to learn.
6.    Provide plenty of examples
While one or two examples may be sufficient for most students, extra examples may be required for English language learners to understand is required of them. Never simply assume that English language learners understand- they may be hesitant to admit that they need more explanation or to ask questions in front of the class. Instead, speak with the English language learners after they have received the assignment to be sure that they understand the instructions and to give them an opportunity to ask any questions privately.
7.    Create a comfortable learning environment
Last but not least, it is important for students, especially those learning English as a second language, to be comfortable. Be sure that students feel free to ask questions that will aid in their understanding. Have an open door policy so that students can not only discuss academic difficulties, but other problems that may be affecting them as well. Offer encouragement, praise, and constructive criticism when necessary, but always be culturally sensitive. When students feel comfortable in the classroom, learning is much easier.

            Many teachers feel at a loss when it comes to teaching English language learners- either because they do not have the time to make the extra effort or because they do not know how. These seven steps will require only a little more time, but will vastly increase the chances of success for English language learners in your classroom.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

"Why doesn't this new kid talk?"

Often times, teachers come to me frustrated because a new student will not communicate with classmates in English or the native language. They are frustrated that despite their efforts to teach simple phrases and engage the child in even minimal spoken conversation, the child will not speak. This does not mean that the child doesn't like you! He or she is just in their silent period, and they're not ready to speak yet.

Why is there a silent period?
If you've ever traveled to another country, even for a short period of time, then you understand how shocking a new culture and a new language can be. Add to that a new school environment and a different language, and it is no surprise that the child is hesitant to speak. The silent period is not without purpose, however. Krashen asserts that during the silent period, students are adjusting to their new environment and beginning to learn their second language through input.

A personal exmple
Here's a powerful example. Two years ago, a little Vietnamese girl, we'll call her "Tina", came into my middle school classroom. For the first few months, she almost never spoke other than during classroom activities. One day, there was a puddle on my floor from the leaky window, and my sweater was very close to falling off my chair and into the puddle. Tina gasped, pointed and said "Miss! Your jacket!" All of which was vocabulary that she had learned in class through input.

For the rest of the first year that she was with me, her production was still limited to situations where it was necessary, but I knew she was listening and learning. As we worked together the second year, she increased her production more and more, to the point where she would sometimes come to my classroom just to talk to me! She still didn't speak much in class, but all she needed was a trustworthy ear and a comfortable environment.

How does the student's background and class composition affect the silent period?
Another variable that can affect the silent period is the student's culture and the number of speakers of their native language that are in the classroom. In my experience, Asian students, because of their culture, are more precise and will often wait until they are sure that they can produce correct sentences before speaking. Latino students tend to be more gregarious and more focused on the message than on the correctness of the message, and will often come out of their silent period more quickly. Another factor to consider is that Latino students may come out of their silent period sooner due to the higher numbers of native Spanish speakers in the school population.

So what can I do to help my newcomers?
Continue to provide opportunities for the student to acquire necessary vocabulary and sentence structures through comprehensible input. At the early Newcomer stage, it is appropriate to focus on BICS, or basic interpersonal communication skills, as these skills are most immediate need for the student to navigate daily life. Provide plenty of modeling- I always greet my students at the door and say "Good morning _____! How are you today?" I teach the correct responses to my newcomers, and then allow them to learn by listening to me and their classmates. Repetition is also key- we repeat this ritual each morning. Within days, the students are able to provide standard responses, and then within weeks, they provide widely varied and personalized responses.

Also, provide a comfortable environment. Ensure that the students in your classroom are compassionate and helpful, and do not make fun of the Newcomer's attempts at English. According to Krashen's Affective Filter Hypothesis, the affective filter is a sort of emotional screen that can affect the student's language learning. If the student is uncomfortable or nervous, the affective filter is up and language learning is difficult. Pushing the student to produce language when he or she is not ready can also raise the affective filter. When the student is comfortable and feels free to make mistakes, then optimal language learning can occur.

Again, don't be discouraged if your Newcomer doesn't speak right away- respect the silent period and give your student time to learn through input. You'll be amazed at what our students can learn on their own, just through listening!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

"But he speaks great English! Why does he have so much trouble?"

Blame it on the BICS and the CALPS.

Oh No! More ESL acronyms!! I know many of you are rolling your eyes, because few disciplines have as many acronyms as ESL. In this case, these are two acronyms that you need to be aware of because of the very important concepts and distinctions between them.

In 1979, J. Cummins made a very important distinction between the two types of language that can be acquired. According to Cummins, these are Basic Interpersonal Communications Skills (BICS) and Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency Skills (CALPS). Both types of language skills are important for students in our classrooms.

Students need the BICS to do everyday tasks like ask to go to the bathroom, follow directions, make small talk, and interact with peers. For the most part BICS are oral, and most students seem to gain these very quickly after they leave their silent period. According to Cummins, BICS can be fully mastered in 1-2 years. But BICS are just the tip of the iceberg, so to speak.

CALPS are the language skills that students need to be successful on academic tasks in the classroom. CALPS are much more difficult to master; in fact, some native speakers are never able to fully grasp academic language. Cummins says that for a student actively engaged in learning academic language, mastery of CALPS can take 5-7 years.

So what does all of this mean to a classroom teacher? Many very good teachers make the mistake of thinking that just because a student can "speak English" or has mastered BICS, then they are proficient in English. Teachers are confused when a student who is always talking to their peers in what sounds like fluent English struggles with reading, writing, and academic content. This is because the student has not mastered CALPS. Language difficulties often go undiagnosed because many teachers are not able to make the distinction between BICS and CALPS and how they fit into a student's English language development.

One thing that I routinely notice every year when looking over my students English Language Proficiency test results (whether those results come from the Access, the ELDA or the LAS Links test) is that students always have much higher scores in speaking and listening than reading and writing. This is because these are the skills that the students use the most. They're always listening (even when we think they're not), whether it's to the teacher, a classmate or the TV. And as their teachers, we know they always seem to be speaking. This is also because these sub-tests allow the students to demonstrate their mastery of BICS.

Reading and writing however, require the use of academic language, or CALPS, which students have a much more difficult time acquiring. This is why many of the suggested strategies like word walls, sentence walls, and explicit vocabulary instruction are so important for our ESL students- it is our chance to model for them the academic language that they are expected to use. We need to not only explicitly teach the vocabulary and meaning of the words, but the structure and context of the academic language we expect them to produce. This means lots of repetition and modeling of the language of your content. It is also important to remember that vocabulary cannot be taught in isolation- it needs to be taught in context.

As I mentioned above, many native students have difficulty mastering academic language. By explicitly teaching and modeling academic language in your classroom, you will not only help ELLs, but all of your students!

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Connecting reading and writing with Post-reading strategies


            A wealth of research indicates that students who take part in a curriculum involving post-reading strategy application have a more successful and meaningful reading experience (Smith, 2003). Applying post reading strategies involves students in what they are reading; enhancing not only their comprehension, but also their appreciation for reading and the knowledge they gain. Post-reading activities in particular help students to analyze, synthesize and consolidate what they have read (Smith, 2003).
            Many students do not develop effective reading strategies on their own; instead they must receive explicit instruction to learn and use these strategies. Students need guided practice and feedback from a teacher to acquire and integrate these very important skills into their reading habits. Research shows that students learn these skills best not in a reading class, but rather when they are incorporated into regular content area classes (Roe et al., 1990).
            Instructional activities that teach reading comprehension should focus on constructing meaning. Authentic reading materials should be employed and read for authentic purposes (Roe et al., 1990). By becoming more active in the reading process, students can learn with the text, and not only from the text.
            However, in order to effectively understand a text, a student must also understand the ways that authors organize and structure text, as well as the literary devices used by authors and their impact on the reader. Writing in response to reading contributes to comprehension because it enables students to understand the ways that authors express ideas using written language (Roe et al., 1990).
            Cooperative learning activities are especially beneficial in teaching reading strategies. According to Forget (2004), when students work together to construct meaning from a text, they learn more deeply in addition to helping one another learn how to learn. Students at different levels can gain understanding from each other’s insights, perceptions, and even mistakes (Forget, 2004).
            Cooperative learning involves small groups of students learning subject matter by working together to solve a problem. In a classroom where literacy is emphasized, the problem to be solved is usually an interpretation of text. The teacher’s role in the process should be that of a facilitator, not a dispenser of knowledge (Forget, 2004).
            Others agree that cooperative learning is especially important for English language learners when learning content in English. Talking and interacting with peers is very engaging for students and increases the opportunities they have to think about, discuss, and write about what they have learned (Robertson, 2008).
 Forget (2004) asserts that in order to motivate students to think about, learn, and discuss what they have read, we must use an instructional framework which gives students the opportunity to become active in their own learning and reading (Forget, 2004).
According to Forget, this framework should involve assisting students in setting a purpose prior to reading and connecting to their own prior knowledge about the topic. During the reading, the teacher should assist students in following their purposes for reading and monitoring their own comprehension. After reading, teachers should assist students in critical thinking by creating opportunities for students to analyze and synthesize the text, as well as extend their thinking beyond the text (Forget, 2004).
Teachers also need to take time to model the strategies they expect students to use. As teachers and accomplished readers, we can often forget how overwhelming a text can be for a struggling reader (Robertson, 2008). We must remember that these readers struggle because they don’t have those skills, so we must adjust our teaching and explicitly teach and model the skills and strategies we want our students to use.
            Especially important for success in content area reading is the understanding of content specific vocabulary. This is even more important for English language learners, who need much more direct and explicit instruction in vocabulary. It is important however, not to overwhelm the learner with new vocabulary. Instead, pick only what is most essential for each new chapter or unit. Content area terms should be chosen for their use in helping children apply the concepts they are learning (Silverman, 2009).
            It is important to be sure students can understand what they are expected to read. According to Krashen (2003), students acquire language by understanding input containing words and structures they are familiar with, as well as a few new words and structures. Pictures and body movements are especially important for beginners, but are helpful for all English language learners in setting context. Krashen asserts that if we provide students with enough interesting, engaging comprehensible input, language acquisition will occur (Krashen, 2003).
            Krashen (2003) also asserts that it is important to teach students selective reading: that is, reading to solve a problem. Krashen (2003) says, “It may be the case that reading is useful to us only when it is relevant to a problem that we are working on…” (Krashen, 2003, p.73). When students are given a problem to solve, they will retain the information they read if the information is related to the problem (Krashen, 2003).

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Using reading to drive language acquisition for ELLs


            Experts agree reading is one of the most important ways for both native language speakers and ELLs to acquire language and content. When students are exposed to a variety of different texts, they are more likely to find something that interests them. Both fiction and non-fiction texts can be effectively used to build vocabulary, sentence structure, and grammatical awareness, as well as pique interest. Additionally, writing is a natural extension and use of the skills acquired while reading, and should be paired with reading activities (Kern, Andre, Schilke, Barton & McGuire 2003). The debate begins when people start discussing the best way to teach reading. Whether or not a best way exists, there are many methods that can be effective for both native language students and ELLs.
      
However, it seems that teaching reading isn't so much teaching as “guiding”.  Suits (2003) discusses her experiences in integrating ELLs into guided reading groups with native speakers. She came to the conclusion that guided reading groups give the children an opportunity to work at their level in a comfortable environment where they can share and clarify ideas- using English to learn from one another.

The guided reading groups designed and implemented by Sink (2003) employ several principles that O'Malley and Pierce (1996) find essential to the instruction of reading. First, students should be provided with extensive in-class reading opportunities. If you want them to have time to read- give them time. Additionally, direct strategy instruction is suggested by O'Malley and Pierce (1996, p. 95) and reinforced by Sink's (2003) experiences at the American School in Holland. This means explicitly teaching students the strategies that we expect them to use to become active readers and increase their understanding, and then giving them opportunities to use those strategies both with guidance and independently.
           
Additionally, as ESL professionals, we must not forget the necessary amount of scaffolding that our students need. They do not have the same educational, cultural, and often socio-economic background that native students do. It is our job to provide it for them through explanation, modeling, and providing samples of what is expected (Sink, 2003, p.4). We can do this through activating and building their background knowledge through appropriate activities. Writing, as a natural extension of the reading process, can be integrated through summarization and literature response logs (O'Malley and Pierce, 1996), and gives students a chance to personalize what they've read.
         
If we can forget about which method is best to teach reading, and focus on which methods are effective, then I believe that we can come up with an effective curriculum that provides students of all proficiencies with the tools that they need to be successful readers. It just times time, thought, and a little elbow grease.